More Liveable” Speculations: the Gender of SF in Margaret Atwood’s Short Story “Oursonette” and in the Comic Book / Graphic Novel War Bears

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26485/ZRL/2020/63.1/2

Keywords:

contemporary English-language literature, speculative fiction, Margaret Atwood, comic books, graphic novels, “Canadian whites,” superheroines, gender discourse

Abstract

Taking into account the broadness of the SF genre, the article commences with examining the difference between speculative fiction and science fiction, as outlined specifically by Donna J. Haraway and Margaret Atwood. Drawing on Atwood’s understanding of speculative genre, the paper analyses two separate but intertwined artistic forms: a classic short story with embedded dialogue and a comic book / graphic novel based upon the extended version of the earlier narrative. The short story “Oursonette” was written by Atwood as a part of a national project of artists commemorating the sesquicentennial anniversary of the Canadian Confederation. It depicts Victory in Europe Day, 8 May 1945, from the perspective of Canada and its impact upon the publishing of “Canadian whites,” otherwise known as WECA comic books. Partially black-and white War Bears (2019), referring to the tradition of “Canadian whites” comics, is a modern graphic novel, co-authored with Ken Steacy, which essentially uses the plot of Atwood’s “Oursonette” as the foundation for drawing an expanded story that precedes and follows the original. The narrative is not simply elaborated, a new dimension of visual imagery and a significant layer of intersectionality have changed its meaning to a large extent. The article analyses those alterations in detail to come to a conclusion as to whether they are beneficial or redundant to the original form and content. Thematically, the paper probes the gendered dimension of Atwood’s (and partly Steacy’s) rendering of the superheroine subcategory, with regard to SF genre and its literary convention. The article compares how this issue is represented in both examined literary genres: a narrative by Atwood and a comic book / graphic novel by Atwood and Steacy.

References

“An Interview with Trina Robbins,” Part 1 (2012), http://comicsbulletin.com/interview-trina¬-robbins-part-1/ [access: 10.09.2019].

Atwood Margaret (2011), In Other Worlds: SF and the Human Imagination, Virago, London.

— (2019a), Foreword. Margaret Atwood and Ken Steacy [in:] War Bears, Dark Horse Books, Milwaukie.

— (2019b), “Oursonette:” Addendum, Margaret Atwood and Ken Steacy, War Bears, Dark Horse Books, Milwaukie.

Atwood Margaret, Steacy Ken (2019), War Bears, Dark Horse Books, Milwaukie.

Bell John (2006), Invaders from the North: How Canada Conquered the Comic Book Universe, Dundurn, Toronto.

Cocca Carolyn (2016), Superwomen: Gender, Power and Representation, Bloomsbury Academic, New York.

Haraway Donna J. (2016), Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene, Duke UP, Durham – London.

Hicks Olivia, Round Julia (2016), WWWWD: What would Wonder Woman do? An Interview with Trina Robbins, “Studies in Comics”, December, vol. 7 Issue 2, eprints.bournemouth. ac.uk › STIC_7.2_1_int_Hicks_R [access: 10.09.2019].

Hix Lisa (2014), “Women who Conquered the Comics World”, https://www.collectorsweekly. com/articles/women-who-conquered-the-comics-world/ [access: 10.09.2019].

Kocmarek Ivan (2017), “Alternatives within an Alternative Form: Canadian Wartime Creators: Bus Griffiths, Avrom Yanovksy, “Ab Normal,” Tedd Steele, and Jack Tremblay” [in:] The Canadian Alternative: Cartoonists, Comics and Graphic Novels, eds. Grace D., Hoffman E., University Press of Mississippi, Jackson.

— (2019), Introductions: War Bears [in:] Atwood M., Steacy K., War Bears, Dark Horse Books, Milwaukie.

Madrid Mike (2016), The Supergirls: Fashion, Feminism, Fantasy, and the History of Comic Book Heroines, Exterminating Angel Press, Minneapolis.

Robbins Trina (1999), From Girls to Grlzz: A History of Women’s Comics from Teens to Zines, Chronicle Books, San Francisco.

— (2019), Introductions: War Bears [in:] Atwood M., Steacy K., War Bears, Dark Horse Books, Milwaukie.

Steacy Ken (2019), Foreword. Margaret Atwood and Ken Steacy [in:] War Bears, Dark Horse Books, Milwaukie.

The Canadian Alternative: Cartoonists, Comics and Graphic Novels (2017), eds. Grace D., Hoffman E., University Press of Mississippi, Jackson.

Downloads

Published

2020-09-18

How to Cite

Ostalska, K. (2020). More Liveable” Speculations: the Gender of SF in Margaret Atwood’s Short Story “Oursonette” and in the Comic Book / Graphic Novel War Bears. Zagadnienia Rodzajów Literackich The Problems of Literary Genres, 63(1), 21–37. https://doi.org/10.26485/ZRL/2020/63.1/2